Dr. Henry Jekyll/Mr. Hyde
NOTE: A tie. Wallace Beery (The Champ) had one vote less than Mr. March, and rules at the time stated that if any achievement came within three votes of the First Award, it would be considered a tie.
Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde
3 nominations, 1 win
Dr. Jekyll faces horrible consequences when he lets his dark side run wild with a potion that transforms him into the animalistic Mr. Hyde.